ELI5: Explain Like I'm 5

Elevator paradox

Imagine you are in a tall building and you want to ride the elevator from the ground floor to the top floor. The elevator moves quickly, but you start to wonder about what would happen if you dropped a ball inside the elevator while it was moving.

At first, you might think that the ball would fall straight down to the ground (or the floor of the elevator) just like it would if you dropped it while standing still. However, this is not actually what happens.

In fact, due to a phenomenon called the elevator paradox, the ball will appear to fall diagonally, in a curved trajectory, when observed from outside the elevator. This is because the ball has the same velocity as the elevator, and therefore it continues moving forward while also being pulled down by gravity.

To understand this concept, imagine that you are on a train that is moving at a constant speed. If you drop a ball inside the train, it falls straight down because it has the same velocity as the train. However, if the train suddenly stops, the ball will continue to move forward due to inertia, and it will appear to move diagonally from outside the train.

Now, imagine that instead of stopping suddenly, the train starts accelerating upwards. In this case, the ball will appear to move diagonally downwards from outside the train, because it has the same velocity as the train but is also being pulled down by gravity.

The same principle applies to elevators. If the elevator is accelerating upwards, objects inside the elevator will appear to fall diagonally downwards when observed from outside. Conversely, if the elevator is accelerating downwards, objects inside the elevator will appear to fall diagonally upwards.

So, even though it might seem counterintuitive, the path that an object takes when dropped inside an elevator depends on the motion of the elevator itself. This is the elevator paradox!