ELI5: Explain Like I'm 5

Two-level utilitarianism

Okay kiddo, let me try to explain two-level utilitarianism in a way that is easy to understand.

So, you know how sometimes we have to make choices that affect other people? Like when we decide to share our toys or help someone who is hurt? That's called ethics. And two-level utilitarianism is a way of thinking about ethics.

Basically, it says that there are two levels of ethics. The first level is what we call "rules." These are like the rules that our parents or teachers might give us, like "share your toys" or "don't hit people." These rules are important because they help us get along with each other and make society a better place.

The second level is what we call "consequences." This means thinking about what will happen as a result of our actions. So if we share our toys, the consequence might be that our friends are happy and we have fun together. But if we hit someone, the consequence might be that they get hurt and we get in trouble.

The tricky part is that sometimes the rules and the consequences don't always match up. For example, what if following a rule like "always tell the truth" would lead to a bad consequence, like hurting someone's feelings or getting someone in trouble unfairly? That's when we might have to think more carefully and decide which level of ethics is more important in that situation.

Overall, two-level utilitarianism is a way of balancing the rules and the consequences to make the best ethical decisions we can. It's not always easy, but thinking about both levels can help us be more thoughtful and fair to everyone involved.