ELI5: Explain Like I'm 5

Boy or Girl paradox

The boy or girl paradox is all about probability, and it involves trying to guess the gender of a newborn baby based on some information you have been given. Imagine you are playing a game where you are told that a family has two children, and you are asked to guess the gender of the older child. You are also given a clue that one of the children is a boy. What would be your guess?

At this point, you might think that your answer should be "boy," since you know there is at least one boy in the family. But wait a minute! What if the other child is also a boy? That's a possibility, right? In that case, your answer would have been wrong.

So, let's break it down further to help you understand what's really going on here. If we consider all the possible combinations of genders that two children in a family can have, we get the following list:

1. Boy-Boy
2. Boy-Girl
3. Girl-Boy
4. Girl-Girl

Now, let's look at the clue you were given, which is that one of the children is a boy. That means we can eliminate option 4 from our list, since we know that there is at least one boy in the family. That leaves us with three possible combinations:

1. Boy-Boy
2. Boy-Girl
3. Girl-Boy

Given this information, what is the probability that the older child is a boy?

If you answered 2/3, you are correct! The reason for this is that there are two scenarios in which the older child is a boy (options 1 and 2), out of a total of three possible scenarios. So, if we were to repeat this game many times and keep track of our guesses, we would be right two-thirds of the time when we guessed "boy" as the gender of the older child.

In summary, the boy or girl paradox is a probability puzzle that involves guessing the gender of a child based on some information. It shows that even seemingly simple questions can have surprising or counterintuitive answers, and that understanding probability can be a valuable skill in many areas of life.